SEEKING OUT THE BENCHMARKS

‘Benchmarking’ is one of commercial and corporate life’s buzz words. ‘We need to benchmark this!’ the cry goes up. And what do they mean? Just that they need to compare their business with others doing similar things – a mixture of industrial espionage and jealousy.

It is, of course, wrapped up in management-speak; so the Wikipedia definition tells us that ‘Benchmarking is the process of comparing one’s business processes and performance metrics to industry bests or best practices from other companies. Dimensions typically measured are quality, time and cost. In the process of best practice benchmarking, management identifies the best firms in their industry, or in another industry where similar processes exist, and compares the results and processes of those studied (the ‘targets’) to one’s own results and processes. In this way, they learn how well the targets perform and, more importantly, the business processes that explain why these firms are successful.’

So that’s clear. But why ‘benchmarking’? The term comes from the small marks incised on buildings around the country that often go unnoticed but were formerly an important part of the country’s surveying and map-making. Benchmarks abound in Britain – but they are less noticed than their younger companion markers, the small, triangular, white-painted pillars that sit on the tops of hill – the ‘trig points’.

Trig points – more formally ‘triangulation stations’ – were once a vital help in the mapping of the country. Triangulation is a way of surveying the land has a long history. The idea was first used by the Flemish physician, mathematician, cartographer, philosopher, and instrument maker Gemma Frisius (despite the name, a man). In the mid-16th century he worked out that it is possible to find the exact location of a point on the landscape by measuring the angles to it from known points. The known points rely on the establishment of a fixed baseline; if the length of the baseline is exact, you can measure the angle from each end and work out exactly where your third point is. And when you’ve set your baseline, you can cover a whole country with your triangulations, working from point to point.

Continental countries were ahead of Britain in triangulation, and it wasn’t until 1784 that our baseline was laid out, at the prompting of Joseph Banks, by Major-General William Roy, whose work led to the establishment of the Ordnance Survey. The baseline was 5.19 miles long, and was on Hounslow Heath. The Ordnance Survey’s triangulation began in July 1791 with a recalibration of the baseline, and in earnest in the spring of 1792.

You may think that trig points are contemporary with this triangulation, which took many years. They are not; they date only from the re-triangulation, dating from the mid-1930s; some were put in place as late as the 1960s. And with satellite technology they are now redundant, although a few are still in use as part of the current Global Positioning System (GPS) technology. And it’s possible now to ‘adopt’ a trig point, should you feel the need.

Meanwhile, there was a requirement to measure height above sea level. Some of this could be done by the triangulation method, but it was felt that a more accurate method was needed. In the 1840s the Ordnance Survey established a mean sea level at the Victoria Docks in Liverpool. Using this, they undertook the ‘primary levelling’ of the country – in other words, they worked out the exact heights of the landscape from the agreed sea level.

Marking local levels was done by benchmarks, which consist of a line that is (usually) chiselled into a stone structure that is reckoned to be unlikely to move – a church, a castle, a bridge or a strong wall, for example. Below the line and pointing up to it is a broad arrow, the military symbol which has been the mark of the Board of Ordnance since the 16th century, and was derived from the coat of arms of Sir Philip Sydney, Master of Ordnance in 1585. Beware, though, if the arrow is above the line and pointing down; it means you are below sea level. There is apparently one such benchmark in Norfolk.

Most existing benchmarks date to the nineteenth century, though some were put in place in the early 20th when mean sea level was recalculated at Newlyn in Cornwall – what’s called the ‘Ordnance Datum Newlyn’. There are two types of benchmark – ‘fundamental bench marks’, of which there are about 190, and lower-order benchmarks. There were hundreds of thousands of the latter, and it’s estimated that around 500,000 still remain.

Like trig points, they are no longer used – and they can easily disappear. In Ripon we seem to have lost quite a number of these lower-order benchmarks. They are marked on the 6-inch Ordnance Survey maps of the city; the 1890s map shows a great many. Some still remain – there is a good example on the east side the obelisk in the Market Square. There is one on a wall near the clock tower (but not one on the clock tower itself, which was built after the benchmark network was established).

The most obvious place, of course, is on the cathedral, and, indeed, one is shown on the maps on the south west tower, facing west. But a careful examination of the wall failed to locate it; it is possible that, being as usual at a low level, the benchmark has been covered up in the refashioning of the cathedral forecourt. Others in the city have disappeared when buildings were demolished.

So look out for benchmarks as you go around the city – and if you find the one on the cathedral, please let us know! And next time you hear the management whizz-kids extolling the values of ‘benchmarking’, reflect on the real meaning of the word – those small symbols carved in the stones of the city and beyond.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.