REMEMBERING ‘VICTORIAN CHURCH ART’

Forty-three years ago this month an exhibition in the Victoria and Albert Museum opened the eyes of many people to the great wealth of artworks – stained glass, embroidery, metalwork, carving, bookbinding – that had been produced during the nineteenth century for the churches of Britain.
The exhibition, ‘Victorian Church Art’, was the first major national exhibition to deal with the subject.

The fact that it took 70 years from the end of the Victorian age for its ecclesiastical works to achieve this accolade speaks volumes about the attitude of the earlier 20th century to the taste of its immediate forebears. At the beginning of the century many were only too pleased to have been able to slough off what they considered the deplorable taste of Victorian times; we can see the result in the extravagantly decorated exterior of Ripon’s Spa Baths to get an idea of how this new freedom expressed itself.

As far as church art is concerned, the foreword to the catalogue for the exhibition puts the delay in the proper appreciation of such art down to the politeness of art historians: ‘Decorative art objects in churches have generally been kept in use as their donors intended, and students of design, even those who haunt churches for the sake of their architecture, have hesitated to intrude upon the enclaves of religion with a mundane curiosity.’ It’s not often these days that you’ll find a sentence like that written – neither from a stylistic point of view nor from a reluctance of people to ask to see what interests them.

But in the 1970s there was more deference – and the interest in Victorian art was really still the taste of a small minority. Among those who were known to be interested were some whose names appear in among the Consultative Committee for the exhibition. The one most likely to be recognised today is Sir John Betjeman, who was to become Poet Laureate in 1972. Along with him were his close friend the artist John Piper, and Professor Sir Nikolaus Pevsner, whose association with Betjeman was more equivocal. Also on the committee was Professor Phoebe Stanton, the leading expert on the architect Pugin. There was, too, a good handful of eminent clergymen, both Anglican and Roman Catholic, including the Reverend Basil Clarke, author of the first important work in 19th century church architects.

And what was the remit of these eminent people? It was ‘to make a representative exhibition in which as many designers as possible are featured, and occasionally we have waived our insistence on quality in order to be comprehensive.’ They point out that in the 19th century ‘the major architects designed not only buildings, but the furnishings inside them.’ From these premises they put together an exhibition of great diversity.

It starts with ‘Early Victorian Designers’ – most of whom used simple Gothic style that was really no different from the Georgian style that had preceded it – this is where the ‘insistence on quality’ is most obviously waived. This is a brief section and soon gives way to the first of the important designers, Pugin. In contrast to the earlier works, Pugin’s designs seem genuinely medieval, and, working mainly for the Roman Catholic Church, he produced a vast range of objects – illuminated manuscripts, vestments, thuribles and incense boats, bishops’ mitres, crosses and candlesticks and many other sorts of metalwork. Among the objects in the exhibition was Pugin’s design for a stained glass window at Bolton Priory.

At the time Pugin was working, there was a stirring in the Church of England – the Oxford Movement wanted to bring the church back to its Catholic roots, both theologically and in terms of design and ritual. A parallel movement at Cambridge, the Cambridge Camden Society, was set up to promote proper church architecture and furnishing, which to them meant churches in the medieval Gothic style with long chancels containing altars, as well as all the furnishings and ritual objects to go with this newly-recovered idea of the beauty of worship. The exhibition suggests that for the rest of the century the major architects and designers were serving this end.

After Pugin the exhibition dealt with William Butterfield (architect of Baldersby St James Church) and then William Burges; among the exhibits was the font cover, showing John the Baptist and Jesus, lent by the church of Christ the Consoler at Skelton-on-Ure. The roll call of great Victorian architects continues with G E Street and then Sir Gilbert Scott, who restored Ripon Cathedral. These is a section of lesser or specialist designers, including Thomas Willement who designed the heraldic Grantley window in Ripon Cathedral. Slightly oddly, these lesser men included the great architect John Loughborough Pearson, whose work, including some great Yorkshire churches like that of South Dalton, was yet to be properly appreciated.

Then there were sections on Victorian designs for St Paul’s Cathedral and for the royal mausoleums at Frogmore in Berkshire, before it reached another important figure, Yorkshire-born J F Bentley and his designs, mainly in metalwork, for his Westminster Cathedral. Then, as might be expected, comes William Morris who, in 1971, was better known for his wallpaper than his church art, and after him another Yorkshire architect, G F Bodley. A separate section on the Arts and Crafts movement of the end of the century follows. One figure of importance here is the designer and metalworker Henry Wilson; his pulpit in Ripon Cathedral, though as late as 1913, is part of the movement, too.

So how did the ‘Victorian Church Art’ exhibition affect later thought? It certainly opened the eyes of many people to the fact that Victorian design is not ugly but possesses and artistic integrity that is as representative of its time as that of any other period. It also paved the way for Victorian architecture and design to be appreciated in its own right and gave us a new perspective on a once-misunderstood and under-appreciated period.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.