Deoxyribonucleic acid – DNA – has proved one of the most powerful scientific discoveries of the last 150 years. Contrary to popular belief, it wasn’t discovered by Watson and Crick in 1953 (they found its double-helix structure) but by Friedrich Miescher in 1869. By its use we can trace the genetic makeup of all living organisms.
It recently came to the fore when geneticists from the University of Leicester used DNA techniques to make a definite identification of the bones found under one of that city’s car parks as those of King Richard III.
What has this to do with the usual subject of this column, architecture and its history? In many ways, looking at architectural history is very much like looking at DNA – tracing back the different strands through preceding generations until we see just why our buildings today have certain characteristics.
Let’s follow some of those strands from the past to the present, starting as we often do in Ripon, with St Wilfrid’s crypt. Not the most complex piece of architecture, it nevertheless has some interesting features in its architectural DNA. In particular, its round arches show a definite family characteristic with the Romans, the remains of whose buildings were still to be seen in Wilfrid’s day.
The Anglo-Saxons took over this tradition of round arches – often narrow but tall, as they didn’t have the skill of the Romans in leaping wide spaces with arches. When the Normans invaded, though, they brought that skill with them, and were soon erecting huge castles and churches that used massive columns to support impressive arches and vaults.
Then, in the early 12th century, came an innovation; the pointed arch. It first appeared on any great scale in the vault of the nave of Durham Cathedral, completed in 1135. Pointed arches had been used on a very much smaller scale before this, but at Durham the builders realised that because a Gothic arch distributes the weight above it better than a round arch, it had plenty of possibilities for both display and majesty, as well as the practical value of being able to build higher and wider.
For a time round arches and pointed arches were used together, in what came to be called the Transitional style; the walls of Ripon Cathedral’s north and south transepts are excellent examples. Soon, though, Gothic triumphed – that new strand of architectural DNA.
Much impetus was given to it by the rebuilding between 1137 and 1144 of the cathedral of St Denys, outside Paris, by its abbot, Suger. He proved that Gothic could be the great modern style; over the following centuries masons developed it into the light and spacious way of building that characterises structures like Salisbury Cathedral; with its tall lancet windows, this is in the Early English style.
The arrival of the Black Death in the 14th century gave a jolt to the development of Gothic. Its elaboration needed many skilled workmen; the plague killed many of them, so a new style was needed. In England that new style was later known as Perpendicular, with its concentration on vertical lines, initially with little decoration. Windows became grids with minimal ornament – the nave aisle windows of Ripon Cathedral are good examples. Only in the roofs did Perpendicular, in its last phase, break out into something richer – the elaborate fan vaults of King’s College Chapel, Cambridge or King Henry VII’s Chapel at Westminster Abbey are the great examples of the style.
Following this strand of DNA, we can see that the grids of the Perpendicular style became the even-simpler rectangles, with mullions and transoms, of the Elizabethan age; watch Wolf Hall on the television carefully and you’ll see plenty of them (mostly rather too late for the period in which the drama is set, it must be said!). The style, with a little more elaboration, went on into the Jacobean period – but suddenly there was a jolt; foreign DNA was introduced.
This came with Inigo Jones, who, working for the court, brought in the ideas of Palladio for pure classical buildings (in turn based on ancient Rome, so perhaps no more foreign that Wilfrid’s crypt). The Banqueting House in Whitehall and the Queen’s House at Greenwich are Jones’ masterpieces; there would undoubtedly have been more, and the course of English architecture might have been different, had it not been for the Civil War, which brought an end to much building.
When Charles II was returned to the throne in 1660 the English architectural DNA had a more French twist, influenced by Charles’ stay at the French court. In came the Baroque, a style that copied the Roman but added ostentatious decoration and quirky details. Sir Christopher Wren’s St Paul’s Cathedral and his city churches were the first progeny of the style, and were soon followed by the works of John Vanbrugh, like Castle Howard and Blenheim Palace, and of Nicholas Hawksmoor, designer of Ripon’s obelisk which, if it had had the projecting star-shaped canopy he proposed, might have been more baroque than it is!
All through the DNA of English architecture runs a political strand. Different styles were a reflection of different strands of political thought; we can see the Elizabethan grid as an expression of the order of the queen’s reign, the classicism of Inigo Jones as an expression of the Divine Right of Kings (a bit of hubris that led to Oliver Cromwell’s Commonwealth) and the Baroque of Charles II as a loud ‘hurrah’ on the Restoration.
With the death of Charles II towards the end of the 17th century, though, it became even more political, when the DNA of our architectural history became tangled with the struggles between Catholics and Protestants, Tories and Whigs. We’ll continue to follow the strands in next week’s column.
