In 1841 an architect wrote, ‘There should be no features of a building which are not necessary for convenience, construction or propriety. The smallest details should serve a purpose, and construction itself should vary with the material employed.’
Last week’s column left the strands of architectural DNA at the start of the 19th century, at a time when Neo-Classical, Greek and Gothic were all styles that had been tried. The architect who wrote those words in 1841 might, therefore, be thought to be heralding a new age: the age of a new style of architecture – a new strand of DNA. So who was this visionary architect?
In fact it was Augustus Pugin. Most people, if they know of Pugin at all, know him for his decorative work – all Gothic – at the Houses of Parliament. The recent television documentaries about the workings of the Palace of Westminster have frequently shown glimpses of the elaborate interiors of the building – the House of Lords is probably one of the most over-the-top Gothic rooms in the world. So, we may say, ‘He’s a fine one to talk!’, and wonder how he squared his fantasy of the Middle Ages with statements about details serving a purpose and there being nothing unnecessary.
In fact Pugin was, as ever, writing in a partisan way, this time about ‘The True Principles of Gothic Architecture’ – the title of the book in which the quotation appears – and to him Gothic was a perfectly functional style. That it also provided links back to the Catholic Middle Ages, something he wished to revive, was another strand to his polemic.
Many 19th century architects were influenced by Pugin’s ideas; we have only to think of J A Hansom’s St Wilfrid’s Church in Ripon to see how they took up his cause. But Pugin and his followers didn’t have it all their own way. Classical styles continued to be built – built, indeed, sometimes by the same architects; J A Hansom also designed Birmingham’s Town Hall. It is a copy of the Roman Temple of Castor and Pollux, complete with fluted Corinthian columns. Other architects took up other styles, like the Italian Renaissance that was used for many of the London clubs and hotels, or the French Renaissance, like Cuthbert Brodrick’s Grand Hotel in Scarborough.
Some critics found this reliance on old styles depressing, and looked elsewhere for inspiration. One of the places they looked was to the great engineers of the late 18th and early 19th century. They looked to men like Abraham Darby, the builder of Shropshire’s Iron Bridge, and to Thomas Telford, whose Menai Bridge was considered a miracle. The architect Matthew Digby Wyatt wrote of these works, ‘From such beginnings what glories may be in reserve! We may trust ourselves to dream, but we dare not predict.’
One of the greatest influences on a new direction in architecture was Joseph Paxton’s Crystal Palace, built in Hyde Park in 1851. Based on his earlier glasshouses, this was a revolutionary building; it went up extremely fast, was made of pre-fabricated, standard-sized components, and even had little trucks that ran along its gutters to aid the glaziers. Above all, it rejected brick and stone for the modern materials of glass and iron. Pugin hated it, calling it a ‘glass monster’; Ruskin called it a ‘cucumber frame’. Others, though, saw it as a new era in architecture.
The new era took some time to arrive. Cast-iron construction was not used in mainstream architecture immediately, though it influenced more utilitarian structures like railway stations – think of the great curve of the roof of York Station, for example, or the pointed lattice-work of girders at St Pancras in London. Meanwhile, there was a tendency, already begun in 18th-century mills, for functional buildings like offices to develop as a grid of vertical and horizontal elements, sometimes decorated, sometimes plain. This was taken up in the United States and, with the advent of steel framing, led to the development of the skyscraper and, from thence, to the modern age of building, with its ever-greater insistence on height.
But there was another DNA strand that comes from the 19th century, too – that of hand-crafted architecture, using the vernacular of, particularly, country buildings. This was promulgated by Ruskin, but its real advocate was William Morris. His Red House was based in the principles of utility and hand-work, honestly expressing its function in it structure – and it was built by workmen who took pride in their efforts. Morris said, ‘The two virtues most needed in modern life are honesty and simplicity’.
Morris influenced later architects, to a greater or lesser extent. They moved away from Gothic or Classical to other, more homely styles – ‘Queen Anne’ among them. And architects like Hull-born C A Voysey pared down the vernacular style to whitewashed walls, irregular windows, tiled roofs and hand-crafted details like door handles and hinges. This style became very popular, and has influenced the design of houses – including the houses that make up the massive suburban estates of today.
And Morris’s ideas, odd through it may seem, have also influenced the most modern buildings, like the Beijing Bird’s Nest Stadium, the Imperial War Museum in Salford and the London Aquatic Centre. These rely on the single vision of a designer – albeit realised by the wonders of modern technology and a whole army of specialists. It seems we now have the ability to realise any architectural design we can conjure up – though it may sometimes be necessary to call to mind Pugin’s ‘convenience, construction and propriety’ – cleverness for its own sake is not always a good thing.
And where will architecture’s DNA take us next? There are, no doubt, students in the schools of architecture who think they know; yet, whatever ideas they have about modernity, they will have been influenced by what their forebears have passed down to them.
