ARCHITECTURAL TOKENISM

‘Architectural tokenism’ is not a phrase that is in common usage; Google, that arbiter of popularity, gives only eight instances of it – six from the US, one from Tasmania and a final one that may be British. This is rather odd, as architectural tokenism is all around us – even in Ripon.

So what is architectural tokenism? The Oxford English Dictionary defines ‘tokenism’ as ‘the practice of making only a perfunctory or symbolic effort to do a particular thing’ – in other words, making a gesture towards something that others may think is desirable but which seems to the one making the gesture to be futile. Or, to put it more simply, a sop – ‘a thing of no great value given or done as a concession to appease someone whose main concerns or demands are not being met’ (the OED again).

Architectural tokenism, therefore, is a way in which designers and planners include something in a design that, they feel, should satisfy any objectors to their scheme – though, in fact, they hope to get their scheme passed with little change.

This may be complicated in theory, but we see it everywhere in practice. One of the sights of Ripon is ‘St Wilfrid in his bath’ – the figure of the saint that is affixed, within its protective concrete shell, on the wall of the NatWest bank in the Market Square. The figure once stood on the gable of the bank’s predecessor, a fine façade in the Renaissance style that was rather more ornamental than that of the current building. When the original building was demolished, poor Wilfrid was toppled from his perch and used as a token gesture in the forlorn hope that it would make observers think that the demolition was perhaps not as complete as it really was.

There is tokenism, too, on the Square’s east side. When The Arcade– perhaps not the most architecturally-distinguished part of Ripon – was constructed, the entrance to it was marked by the introduction of a pair of Doric columns supporting an entablature. What is the purpose of this addition to the Square? The argument, one supposes, is that it both marks the entrance to The Arcade and ‘fits in’ with the style of the Square – though putting a pseudo-Georgian entrance amid a range of largely 19th-century buildings may be considered a bit odd.

The Arcade columns are not the most egregious of such tokenism. We have only to look at the rash of thick, fluted columns that decorate the doorways of many so-called ‘neo-Georgian’ houses that are in fact merely modern brick boxes; of the attached ‘beams’ that are meant to fool the viewer into thinking that these are Tudor structures, even though it is obvious to everyone they were built within the last couple of decades; or of the twee wrought-iron ‘Juliet balconies’ that decorate ‘town houses’ in the hope of giving them an air of Parisian bohemianism.

It seems that columns exert an unusual fascination to anyone prone to architectural tokenism. Take the 36 bus to Harrogate to see a fine example of this – the columns that are attached to the exhibition hall next door to the Royal Hall. By no stretch of the imagination can they be called functional – they support nothing, and have steel beams protruding from their capitals. So why are they there?

The answer is that they are intended to make observers think that this is part of Harrogate’s history (though plainly it is not – or at least, not yet). They are a reproduction of the row of Greek Doric columns that were part of the entrance to Harrogate’s ‘Cheltenham Pump Room’ – later the Spa Concert Hall – and are now to be found in the gardens at Harlow Carr. You may not, of course, think, this is a logical answer to the ‘Why are they here?’ question . . .
Sometimes, at least, the token columns are the real thing – it’s just that the rest of the building has disappeared around them. There are plenty of examples all around the world – there’s a good example in Perth, Australia, where six Ionic columns still survive on a modest classical façade – while behind it looms a glass and concrete skyscraper.

We have nothing on that scale in Ripon, but architectural tokenism is alive and well and still going on. One recent example can be found on the unattractive and ill-placed block that is the new care home beside the Harrogate Road roundabout, where attached to one wall of the brick-and-render building is a single, narrow chimney built of stone. What is its point? Why stone? Are we meant to think it adds some historical reference – ‘Ah, a limestone chimney! How wonderful! It links the whole structure to Ripon’s glorious past’. If so, it fails.

And we are in danger of getting another, even worse example. The original plans for the proposed McCarthy and Stone development on the Police Station site showed a flat-roofed, square-dormered structure. Vigorous representations to the architect and developers were made at public meetings and in writing by many people, arguing that the design was not taking any account of the surrounding buildings, especially the tall-gabled Victorian terraces adjacent and opposite, nor of the fact that the site is in the Ripon Conservation Area. They were urged to go away and think again.

They laboured, and produced a mouse of an alteration – the square dormers became pointed! The rest was left exactly as before. Ripon Civic Society, Ripon City Council and many others have argued that this is simply not good enough – and we know from other McCarthy and Stone developments that they can do better.

This is an important site and deserves something more than this architecture tokenism. It now behoves the Harrogate Borough Councillors who make the decision as to whether to grant planning permission to show that they care about Ripon and have this design considerably improved before it is built. Ripon deserves better than what we are being offered.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.