BEAUTY – A TRICKY SUBJECT

Surveys can tell us anything we want to know – a fact that’s attested daily by newspaper stories that report the ‘findings’ of surveys that underline the prejudices of the company paying for the ‘research’. A survey, as any media guru will attest, is an easy way of getting a client’s name into the papers.

The same goes for advertising. We are meant to be impressed when we are told that 90 per cent of users of a certain product attest to its wonderful properties or functionality; we are not meant to notice that, in small type at the bottom it says something along the lines of ’In a survey of 87 women’. If you do notice, then you begin to worry – 90 per cent of 87 is 78.3 women; how does that work?

There are also the surveys that tell us things that seem obvious anyway; one recently published, after research by The Centre for Performing Science at the Royal College of Music, shows that going to a concert results in a decrease in stress among the audience. Another survey suggests how good it is to sing, especially in a choir – both relaxing and good for social interaction. Anyone who sings will recognise that as a truth they have always known.

We like it when our prejudices are confirmed: that’s why it was good to see a recent survey in a photographic magazine that showed that nearly all Britain’s most scenic areas are in the north – the Yorkshire Dales came second to the Lake District for scenic beauty.

This finding coincides with a Green Paper published last week called ‘A Community Right to Beauty’. The paper was written for Respublica, a non-partisan ‘think tank’, and its publication is supported by a number of organisations that include The Woodland Trust, The National Trust, The Campaign to Protect Rural England, and Civic Voice.

That word ‘Beauty’ is a slippery one: who can agree on its meaning? Philosophers and artists have wrestled for years about its meaning – what was considered beautiful in one age can be just the opposite in another. We have only to think of the fleshy beauties that inhabit the paintings of Reubens with the stick-thin models that inhabit the pages of fashion magazines today to see that ideas of beauty have changed.

The same is true of our appreciation of landscape; what in the 16th and 17th centuries might have been looked at with horror as wild and desolate countryside, through which travel was dangerous and, if possible, avoided, are now the places to which we flock and to which we offer legislative protection in the form of National Park, Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty or Green Belt status.

So beauty, as ever, is in the eye of the beholder, as well as in the aesthetic judgement of the age in which the beholder happens to live. Today most of us would agree that to have access to natural beauty is important. But, as the Green Paper points out, the usual definition of natural beauty deals with ‘the countryside’; it ‘evades completely the beauty that could be created in the ‘everyday’: in urban and rural communities, and all that sit in between; in our schools, public services and spaces; in our buildings, our walks to work and our wider local infrastructure.’

We might suspect a little special pleading here – the parks and open spaces in our urban areas were surely an attempt to overcome just this supposed ignoring of beauty. But there is a more important point made in the publication; that people in households earning more than £45,000 a year had the best access to beautiful places, attractive buildings and spaces and buildings in their local area. And only 54 per cent of all the people questioned thought they had such access.

The authors of the Green Paper believe that access to beauty is a right, not a privilege, and that there should be an emphasis on putting ‘the fiscal incentives and local frameworks in place to properly support local people in acting on their ambitions and desires for the improvement of their locality, or particular buildings, spaces and places.’

In a city the size of Ripon, and in the villages around, we are in a position more fortunate than people who live in the heart – or even the suburbs – of large conurbations. Positioned as we are between the Dales and the Moors we have access to beautiful countryside. Many of us are able to walk from our homes into the fields and woods around us. We also have on our doorstep some of the most beautiful gardens and managed landscapes in the country – above all Studley Royal and Fountains Abbey.

Yet that’s not true of everyone, even in Ripon. People who rely on bus services are less able to get into the countryside, and with the proposed cuts to bus services that will become worse. People with limited mobility may not be able to travel far, if at all, and so are denied some of that beauty. That’s why it is important to protect what we have in the heart of the city, and of our villages. In Ripon we have the Spa Park and Spa gardens; we have the river corridors and the canal; we have many trees, which need to be protected and added to.

We should also be on the lookout for other areas that can be protected and enhanced for public enjoyment. Such areas were at one time called ‘Pocket Parks’. There are several areas of Ripon that could qualify, including the tree-lined land adjacent to the Workhouse Museum garden – itself a piece of environmental improvement. It is up to us to identify such areas, press for their recognition and ensure their protection in future planning policy.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.