Sublime. It’s a word that we use these days as a vague synonym for ‘excellent’ or ‘really good’. Or we may only use it in the rather damning phrase ‘from the sublime to the ridiculous’.
Those who are trained in chemistry may know it as a verb – ‘to sublime’ is used of a solid that, when heated, turns straight into a vapour – like the dry ice much used in stage shows and on television when a director wants to suggest a certain mysterious edge to a performance. This is sublimation – a word that is also applied metaphorically to mean diverting or modifying certain traits of character into a different, often more acceptable form.
The word comes from the Latin ‘sub’ meaning ‘up to’ and (probably) from ‘limen’, which means ‘a threshold or boundary’. So, in ordinary speech, things that are ‘sublime’ have travelled from one sphere to another – crossed a boundary between the ordinary and the extraordinary.
We use it loosely today, but in the 18th century ‘sublime’ had a precise and special meaning – one that had a great influence on the look of some of our greatest landscape gardens. We can see the results at places like Hackfall, Swinton Castle, Plumpton Rocks and How Stean Gorge.
The philosopher of ‘The Sublime’ (making a noun from an adjective) was the writer and statesman Edmund Burke. He had a theory of aesthetics – the branch of philosophy that deals with the nature of art, beauty, and taste – that divided it into two opposites. There was the art that gave pleasure – that was beautiful art; and there was the art that gave pain (mental rather than physical pain, of course) – that was sublime art. Burke thought that the perfection of beauty caused the body to relax, while the sublime caused tension – and that both were necessary to create a rounded human being.
But that doesn’t tell us what the ‘sublime’ was for Burke. His main definition went as follows: ‘Whatever is in any sort terrible, or operates in a manner analogous to terror, is a source of the sublime; The passions which belong to self-preservation turn on pain and danger; they are simply painful when their causes immediately affect us; they are delightful when we have an idea of pain and danger, without being actually in such circumstances; this delight I have not called pleasure, because it turns on pain, and because it is different enough from any idea of positive pleasure. Whatever excites this delight, I call sublime.’
Did you follow all that? In essence, he means that if we experience the idea of fear without being in danger, we can find a response that we like, even if it’s not exactly pleasure. This is the theory that underlined artistic endeavour for part of the 18th century – and of course, is still the underlying rationale behind ‘white-knuckle’ rides at pleasure parks like Lightwater Valley, where we can pay to be frightened in the most pleasurable way.
There were attempts by painters to introduce the Sublime into their art; Stubbs painted horses attacked by lions (and Stubbs influenced Delacroix, who also painted frightened horses). There are Sublime landscapes, notably by Turner and, in megalomaniac style, by John Martin. John Ward’s massive (14ftx11ft) canvas depicting ‘Gordale Scar’, in Tate Britain, is a prime example of how to convert real, intimidating landscape into art.
And then there were the landscapers who wanted to imitate art – to introduce the Sublime into their gardens. How should they do it? One of their first moves had to be to get a decent site; that’s where Hackfall scores, with its setting in the deep gorge of the River Ure. Plumpton Rocks, too, has the right feel for a sublime landscape – the rocky outcrops and the judiciously-dammed lake offer exactly the right feeling. At Swinton, the deep valley is enhanced with rock sculptures and a Gothic bridge.
But an appropriate site alone will not make a garden sublime. There needs to be some way of allowing people to experience that thrill of fear, that frisson that was so desirable. To achieve this, a sublime landscape would have a set route that you were to follow to place you in exactly the right spot to get its full effect. At Hackfall, Mowbray Point, today called ‘The Ruin’ was the first ‘viewing station’; when the north-facing doors were thrown open, privileged visitors were confronted with the sublime panorama of the wooded gorge with, beyond, views to the moors and, on a good day, Roseberry Topping.
You might also need to add paths, walkways and bridges, allowing access to the views – and sometimes those paths and bridges were themselves part of the Sublime experience. At Plumpton Rocks natural fissures in the rocks have been subtly widened to allow visitors to walk through and experience the idea of being crushed as they do so. At How Stean, where the natural rocky gorge was already dramatic, paths have been cut and bridges erected to make it even more thrilling. And, further up the Dales, the Waterfall Walk at Ingleton offers something of the same experience.
The most advanced of these Sublime gardens is at Hawkstone in Shropshire. Here the landscape was already dramatic, with long rocky clefts and overhangs, steep slopes and caves. It has been enhanced with steps and vertiginous walkways. The viewing stations take you to the Awful Precipice and through The Cleft and the Squeeze. Part of a hillside has been hollowed out as a maze of caves that have oval, porthole-like apertures that frame the views. There is also a narrow Alpine Bridge that you can cross at your (exciting) peril.
Sublime landscapes lasted a few years; they were replaced by the slightly tamer Picturesque landscapes – fewer thrills, more prettiness. And the word has also become tamer over the years; but next time you describe your ice-cream or the music of Bach as sublime, the thrill that they give has something in common with our landscapes.
