THROWING OVER THE IDOLS OF RESTORATION

In 627, less than half a century before Wilfrid founded his church in Ripon, a remarkable event took place in East Yorkshire. The story is told in Bede’s ‘History of the English Church and People’. The Northumbrian King Edwin hears the preaching of Paulinus and is persuaded to accept Christianity, but says he must discuss the matter with his advisers – chief among them his pagan High Priest Coifi.

Coifi is immediately persuaded of the truth of the new religion. It is during these discussions that the famous image of the life of man as a sparrow flying into the warmth of a banqueting hall through one door and then out into the night through the other is to be found. In his new enthusiasm, Coifi does more than accept Christianity. He takes a sword and a spear, mounts the king’s horse and rides from the royal palace at Buttercrambe to the heathen temple at the place on the Yorkshire Wolds now called Goodmanham. There he topples the idols he had once served and sets fire to the building.

To Bede this is, of course, entirely a good thing to have done – Christianity overcomes paganism, idols are destroyed, true religion is accepted in the country. Yet, of course, nothing is ever quite so straightforward. Much of Bede’s History tells of continuing battles between the forces of the Christian kings and the unenlightened heathens. And we must suspect that, even in the time of Wilfrid, there were still people whose real allegiance was with the old gods, and who bewailed the loss of their sacred places.

Coifi’s actions at the heathen temple were an example of what later came to be known as iconoclasm – the destruction of images. Such destruction, of both art and of buildings, has long gone on, often in the name of religion or of a political idea – sometimes both together.

Ripon had its fair share of it in its early history, especially when, in 875, the monastery and church founded by Wilfrid was destroyed by Danes, leaving only the crypt as a miraculous survivor. There must have been as much sorrow and heartbreak in Ripon when the monastery was sacked as there was among the pagans when Coifi destroyed the Goodmanham temple.

Think, too, of the destruction wrought nearly a millennium later by the Dissolution of the Monasteries. However much some of these great religious institutions had become more worldly than spiritual, their loss must have seemed to many like a seismic upheaval in the fabric of the land. Places like Fountains Abbey were havens of prayer and scholarship, certainly, but were also immensely important as agricultural, financial and social centres, offering employment to hundreds of people and largely sustaining the local economy.

Seemingly at a stroke of Henry VIII’s pen, the monasteries were no more; their collections were dispersed, their estates snapped up by the king and then doled out to favourites, their employees and the many who relied on their custom and patronage cut off from their sources of income. The remaining monks received pensions or valuable secular benefices: Marmaduke Bradley, the Abbot who surrendered Fountains to the King’s commissioners, received a payoff of £100, together with the prebend of Thorpe in Ripon Minster (worth £22 a year) and the Mastership of the Hospital of St Mary Magdalen (worth another £19). But there was no compensation for most of the others.

Within a generation or so, while there was regret for the loss of such establishments (think of Shakespeare’s description of ‘Bare ruin’d choirs where late the sweet birds sang’ in Sonnet 75) the quality of the ruins themselves began to be appreciated and visited – something that continues unabated today. This would have astonished the medieval mind.

Destruction of buildings has always gone on; Shakespeare’s own house, New Place, was demolished in 1759 by its owner, the Reverend Francis Gastrell, because of the pressure of visitors and the refusal of the council to let him extend his garden. Even shorter-lived was Henry VIII’s most ornate Palace, Nonsuch, which was built in 1538 and lasted only until 1683.

The Victorians were good at clearing away whatever was in their way (much of the Norman Castle at Newcastle, for example), while in the 20th century we both built and knocked down perhaps faster than in any other century – think, for example, of the iconic Quarry Hill Flats in Leeds. Once the largest complex of social housing in the country, it was built in 1938 and demolished in 1978.

Wartime bombing also did much destruction, not only here but, even more perhaps, in Europe; cities like Warsaw have been reconstructed to look as they were, while in Britain we generally built anew. And this question of reconstruction still regularly raises its head. Recently the National Trust announced plans for the fire-gutted Clandon Park in Surrey; most of the important 18th-century rooms will be reinstated as they were, while the upper floors will be treated in a modern style.

The decision, like a similar one at another National Trust house, Uppark in West Sussex, which was fire-damaged in 1989, has caused controversy. There are, though, no plans to restore a third National Trust ruin, Seaton Delaval Hall in Northumberland. Perhaps, like monastic ruins, distance in time lends enchantment; the fire occurred in 1822.

The arguments about such restorations, though, pale before the threat to some of the world’s greatest monuments from religious fundamentalists. The great Roman site at Palmyra in Syria has already suffered; so have the great mosque and library in Timbuktu in Mali. It is said that the vast Roman remains at Leptis Magna in Libya are under threat. As far as possible, very detailed surveys of these sites have been, or are being, undertaken, so if they do vanish we will know what has gone and may, eventually, be able to rebuild them.

Coifi, like the militants of today, believed in his cause. Our outlook on such destruction is formed by our own age and beliefs. The rights and wrongs of destruction and reconstruction are not always as straightforward as we might think.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.