Do you recognise anyone on this list? Lady Elizabeth Wilbraham, Edith Hughes, Mary Townley, Ethel Charles, Isobel Hogg Kerr Beattie. No? Try this one: Sara Losh, Elisabeth Scott, Alison Smithson. Got it yet? Let’s add Zaha Hadid; that should help you.
Perhaps you’ve made the connection; they are all women architects. You can be forgiven for recognising only the last two or three; women architects have hardly had a high profile over the centuries. Lady Elizabeth was said to be the first woman to have practised as an architect; among the buildings attributed to her is Weston Hall in Shropshire, designed in 1671. Mrs Townley, a pupil of Sir Joshua Reynolds, designed a number of buildings in Ramsgate in the late 18th century.
Mrs Hughes is thought to be the first to set up her own practice, in Glasgow in 1920; Miss Beattie, another Scot, vies with her for that honour, setting up at much the same time. In 1898 Ethel Charles was the first woman to be allowed to join the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA). Sara Losh is known for the extraordinary church she designed at Wreay in Cumbria (and little else, it must be said).
Elisabeth Scott (a great-niece of Sir George Gilbert Scott and a second cousin of Sir Giles Gilbert Scott) was the first British architect to win an international architectural competition, for the Shakespeare Memorial Theatre (now the Royal Shakespeare Theatre) at Stratford Upon Avon, in 1927. She used her win to encourage female architects by employing them on the project. Alison Smithson was, with her husband Peter, one of the Yorkshire-born architects featured in this column in 2014; she was a pioneer of Brutalism.
Zaha Hadid is by far the best known of women architects practising today – or perhaps ever. Baghdad-born and now a British citizen (and a Dame), her work includes the London Aquatics Centre for the 2012 Olympics and the MAXXI – the National Museum of 21st-Century Arts in Rome, which won the prestigious Stirling Prize for Architecture. And last week it was announced that she had won the RIBA Gold Medal for Architecture, the first woman to win it in her own right (in 1994 Patty Hopkins won it in tandem with her husband Sir Michael Hopkins).
A Wikipedia search for women architects uncovers a list of several hundred, the vast majority from the second half of the 20th century onwards. Only the most sedulous student of architecture would recognise even half of them. Like women composers (who are perhaps at last being given rather more recognition) women architects are barely a blip on the consciousness of the world. And like women composers (though, perhaps, not like women poets and novelists, who are more in the public eye) women architects need to grasp many technicalities, besides having an artistic flair, before they can make their mark.
There is, of course, no reason that they should not be architects except historical tradition and the formerly-accepted place of women, and hence the lack of opportunity. That they have not been recognised as architects until recently is probably a great loss; what might we have had if only the chances had been there for them and the encouragement given?
Yet the men have dominated – but many of them believed there were male and female aspects of architecture. As early as first century BC the Roman architect Vitruvius was writing in his treatise ‘De Architectura’ of the different characteristics of classical columns; the simple Doric column, with a height six times the width of its base, exhibited ‘the proportions, strength and beauty of the body of a man . . . naked and unadorned’. The Ionic column, with its curled top and fluted column, was like a ‘matron’, while the more slender and ornate Corinthian column was ‘an imitation of the slenderness of a maiden.’
Sexist this may have been, but it was an attitude that long endured: the Doric style was strong and forceful, so was used for buildings like courts and prisons, while the festive and female Corinthian was called upon whenever architects needed to celebrate or to add civic grandeur; Birmingham Town hall is a good 19th-century example of the latter.
But it wasn’t just male architects building in the classical style who looked at architecture in this way; the 19th-century Gothic Revival architects did so, too. In fact, it was a lively debating point among them; Sir Gilbert Scott argued that the merits of his favourite ‘Geometrical Decorated’ style (the style of Ripon Cathedral’s east window) ‘consist chiefly in its retention of the masculine and vigorous style of earlier days.’ This was a point of view shared by William Burges, who favoured a ‘muscular’ French Gothic, as shown by his churches at Studley Royal and Skelton-on-Ure.
Others, though, (many on the Anglo-Catholic side of the Church of England among them) thought that later Gothic, with more flowing lines or, as in the Perpendicular style, with more emphasis on verticality and height, was preferable – that it showed more ‘femininity’ and the caring attitude of the church; the great exponent of this was George Frederick Bodley, a pupil of Scott. His ideas came to dominate church architecture at the end of the 19th and for much of the earlier 20th century; the National Cathedral in Washington DC, designed by Bodley and completed by his pupil Henry Vaughan and his successors, is a triumph of the style.
Can we say that the architecture of today shows either masculine or feminine traits? And has the advent of more prominent women architects had an effect? It may be too early to say, though there is argument on both sides: the Brutalism of Alison Smithson we could class as masculine, the flowing curves of much of Hadid’s work as feminine. But really, we should just celebrate that at long last we may be getting to the point where, like actors, writers, artists and composers, they are just doing their job, whether they are female or male.
