SOME THOUGHTS ON MORTAR

This week, we’ll consider mortar. No, don’t turn the page yet; it’s a more interesting subject than you might think, and considerably more so than paint drying.

First, what does the word mean? There are several meanings listed in dictionaries, and they probably all derive from the same Latin word, mortarium, which was a small, hemispherical vessel in which things were crushed. From the word we get the phrase (and the objects) ‘mortar and pestle’, useful for crushing hard substances for culinary use – and a mortar in that sense retains the same shape as its Roman forebear.

Then we have the military mortar – originally a short gun for projecting bombs into enemy lines. They were apparently first used in Naples in 1435. The first mortars were stubby and cup-shaped – just like the mortars for grinding, though today’s offensive mortars tend to be long tubes, to increase the trajectory of the bombs.

The other use you might have thought about is that oddity of academic dress, the mortar board. Though traditionally seen as evidence of higher academic prowess (though it seems now that even nursery schools have ‘graduations’ complete with mortar-boarded toddlers) the name was originally a joke, comparing the flat, square top with a brick-layers ‘hawk’ or board for holding mortar.

And that brings us conveniently to the architectural use (and misuse) of mortar – something that has been around for at least 8,000 years. Its first proper use as a specially-prepared substance to bind building blocks together is said to have been with mud bricks in Neolithic Pakistan in about 6,500 BC. The first kiln-baked bricks appeared in the Indus Valley three millennia later; these needed a more formal type of mortar, based on gypsum – the same mineral that underlies Ripon and causes so many problems. Gypsum-based mortar was used to build many of the pyramids in Egypt and the Sudan, but as it was soft and easily dissolved in water, it was not practical for wet climates.

It was soon discovered that making mortar from lime gave a better set and made it much more durable. The lime was either derived from quarried limestone or, in suitable areas, from seashells – the stones or shells were crushed (here’s the link with catering equipment) and mixed with sand and water to produce the mortar. The Romans often added volcanic ash to the mix to give extra strength. In China an especially-strong mortar was made by adding a particularly-glutinous rice wine to the mixture.

As well as being strong, lime mortar has other advantages, notably that it lets a building ‘breathe’ – that is, allows the passage of air and moisture – and is flexible enough to cope with any slight movements of a structure over the years.

Lime mortaring was a skilled job and took time. And because early bricks (always hand-made) were never of uniform sizes, the mortar had to bridge gaps of varying sizes – sometimes as much as an inch – in some buildings. Where other materials, like flint or, as in parts of Ripon, rounded river cobbles, were the traditional building material, even more mortar, and more skill, were required.

Lime mortar was used for thousands of years – it was used in the great medieval cathedrals and churches, in palaces, manor houses and cottages alike. Sometimes the mortar was coloured to blend in with the material of the wall; there was a Victorian fashion for black mortar, coloured with soot – the architect John Loughborough Pearson, architect of Truro Cathedral, was very fond of black mortar pointing, which he felt made the carefully-cut stone of his churches stand out.

There was also a fashion in some areas for decorating the pointing by pushing small pieces of stone or chips of flint – even pieces of brick or clinkers – into the mortar while it was still soft. This is called ‘galleting’, and was intended both to strengthen the mortar and also to provide additional visual interest.

Any mortared building put up before the first quarter of the 19th century (and many beyond that date) had lime-mortared joints. But in 1824 a new substance was patented – Portland cement. Though its composition has changed over the years, Portland cement essentially combines the traditional mortar mix with calcium silicates.
Portland cement was a great success – certainly by the 1930s it had superseded lime mortar as the preferred material for building.

Most new building today is likely to use Portland cement; and for many years it was also used in repairing older buildings, too. But despite its ease of use and its strength, Portland cement has serious disadvantages. It is hard and dense, preventing the essential breathing of older structures (modern buildings are designed to cope better with the rigidity that Portland cement provides). It can also look harsh, especially when it is used to repair an ancient wall that has weathered to softness over the centuries. And in the hands of bricklayers and builders who are not trained in repairing old buildings, the effects can be, at best, aesthetically challenging.

Alec Clifton-Taylor, writing in ‘The Pattern of English Building’, said, ‘Mortar . . . should know its manners and not draw attention it itself.’ He was thinking of examples where the mortar pointing of a building is too brutally obvious. The worst sort is ‘ribbon pointing’, where the cement mortar (always cement, never lime) protrudes beyond the wall, squared off with what Clifton-Taylor rightly called ‘two brutal trowel lines’. This is bad enough when a wall is made of regularly-sized stone or bricks; on a wall of flint or cobble it looks like vertical crazy paving.

In the last 50 years, careful lime-mortar pointing has had a revival, and historic buildings are now less likely to have harsh and impervious cement used in their repair. Experienced craftsmen can now be seen reviving a very important skill – so if you live in an older building, just check that when you come to repair it, you respect its materials and let it breathe; it will save you much trouble and expense in the long term.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.