‘What is a Church?’ – Our honest Sexton tells,
‘ ’Tis a tall building with a tower and bells;
Where priest and clerk with joint exertion strive
To keep the ardour of their flock alive.’
George Crabbe wrote those lines in ‘The Borough’ (the source for Benjamin Britten’s opera ‘Peter Grimes’) in 1810. They suggest that in the Georgian period the Church of England was a somnolent place, the parishioners happy to know that the building was there, but scarcely to be roused even by the work of the vicar and the parish clerk.
Even those who aren’t of a religious mind will sometimes visit a church or a chapel – like Philip Larkin in one of his most famous poems, ‘Church Going’ – and assume that through the centuries it has remained much the same, even if, in the case of the Established Church, it switched from being under the sway of the Pope to being the autonomous Church of England with the monarch as its head.
We all know what to expect in most churches we enter – it’s usually an oblong box, sometimes with extra bits at the sides or a projection at the far end where the altar sits. There may well be pews (or perhaps rows of chairs). There will probably be a rail surrounding the altar. There may well be candles on the altar, too. Everything will be decent, in order (perhaps apart from the ‘Children’s Corner’) and, we may think, unremarkable.
But it wasn’t always like this. The history of how churches are organised internally (and therefore, to some extent, how they are designed externally, too) is a long and complicated one, with plenty of dissention and upheaval, argument and even violence along the way.
The earliest Christians had to meet clandestinely because of the persecution that they faced; it was only in the 4th century that the Church was reasonably safe, when Constantine, after a vision of the cross at the Battle of the Milvian Bridge in 312, made Christianity the official religion of the Roman Empire by the Edict of Milan in 313. In some places basilicas, the buildings from which justice was dispensed, were turned into churches; the seat for the bishop was placed where the judges had sat, often in an apse – a curved extension; the apse became a popular design feature in churches thereafter.
In many ways the design and layout of churches changed little for the next few centuries; the altar was placed at the east end (in a cathedral the bishop’s throne – his ‘cathedra’ – was sometimes placed behind it or, more usually, to one side) but the columns and round arches of the Roman age were gradually transformed to the not-dissimilar Romanesque – what in Britain we call the Norman style.
Even with the advent of the Gothic, the layout and ordering of churches didn’t change very much – largely because, in general, the services of the church and the way the hierarchy was structured also changed little. In the late Middle Ages there was a tendency for the number of altars to increase, especially in larger churches with several priests, who had to say Mass every day – hence we find a Chapel of Nine Altars both at Fountains Abbey and Durham Cathedral. And there were, too, the elaborate chantry chapels, endowed by rich families as places where regular masses could be said for the repose of the souls of deceased members.
In many churches there was a distinct difference in the use of the nave – the main body – of the church and the chancel, which was separated from the nave by a screen carrying aloft the rood, or crucifix. The nave was the province of the parish and was often treated as a secular space where people did business, bought and sold and held meals and village events. There was often argument between the religious body that owned the chancel and the villagers who looked after the nave; at Wymondham Abbey in Norfolk a dispute in 1249 went as far as the Pope, who had to arbitrate between the Benedictine monks and the town; that didn’t stop arguments. Eventually the townsfolk built their own tower (pinching the abbey’s bells) and constructed a wall that completely separated their portion from the rest of the building.
This distinction between the use of nave and chancel continued in England even after the Reformation; as late as 1862, when Gilbert Scott was asked to restore Ripon Cathedral, he noted that ‘The parochial congregation had to be crammed into the eastern arm.’ The full use of the nave as well as the chancel of a church is a legacy of the later nineteenth-century. Perhaps the Cathedral’s Angel Dinners and Christmas Fairs are an echo of the former secularised uses of the nave.
Back in the late Middle Ages, churches became ever more crammed with images and elaborate decoration; they were rebuilt to accommodate more and more complex ceremonies. New chapels were added, as chantries or for the use of the trade guilds; aisles multiplied so that the many processions of the church had plenty of scope to perambulate; towers were added to give greater glory to God (and, as at Fountains Abbey, to the man who paid the bill).
But voices were already beginning to be raised, not just about the outer trappings of the medieval Catholic church but about its core theology and beliefs. When Martin Luther supposedly set off the Reformation by nailing his ‘Ninety-Five Theses on the Power and Efficacy of Indulgences’ to the door of All Saints Church, Wittenburg on 31 October 1517 (if he did actually do that – there is some doubt about it) he was just making public the views of a movement that had been underground for half a century or more – a movement that wanted to root out what it saw as the corruption and misdirection of the church.
From this came a revolution not just in theology, but also in the way churches were ordered; we shall consider in next week’s column the changes that it brought about.
