RIPON AND THE M&S BRAND

What’s in a brand? Businesses, especially consumer products and services brands, spend much time, effort and money to build a reputation that keeps the customers coming back time and again. Many celebrities and sports people see themselves as brands, too. Even places aspire to having a brand; Harrogate as a Spa, for example and, of course, Ripon as the ‘Cathedral City of the Dales’.

Now Marks and Spencer – one of the strongest brands around – has proposed a new M&S food store for Ripon at Rotary Way. Bringing M&S back seven years after the small ‘Simply Food’ store closed is understandably being seen by many as affirmation of the city’s vitality. What town wouldn’t want to have its own M&S if it could?

Civic Societies around the country take an interest in their towns and villages, often defending a place’s heritage and character, getting involved with how their place is changing. Often this is about protecting amenities; sometimes it’s arguing for better-quality development. Occasionally it can be more ambitious. Here in Ripon the Civic Society has seen the importance of having a neighbourhood plan – the City Plan – to guide change and to ensure that growth brings benefits for the whole city.

When the Civic Society joined with its partners on the City Plan team there was a real concern for the future of the city centre. The City Development Manager’s column in this newspaper a few weeks ago showed how the city centre is improving. Yet every now and then something is thrown into the mix – like ‘M&S’ – that invites reconsideration of what we expect from the city centre.

So how might we look at this new ‘M&S’ proposal? There are two main issues; where it is and how it impacts on existing shops. And there are other, more detailed points; what it looks like, how vehicles get into it, opening hours, effect on neighbours.

Rotary Way is by no means in the city centre; yet nor is the Aldi store, which has permission and on which work has begun. The proposed ‘M&S’ is far too large to be a local shop. So it should be in the city centre; but where? Without moving something else out of the centre there’s no obvious option that’s available now. Planners will have to consider whether ‘M&S’ needs to wait until a site (or adaptable existing premises) is available in the city centre.

In 2014 a consultants’ report was prepared, as background for the new Local Plan, into the district’s shopping centres: you can find it on Harrogate Council’s website. It showed that Ripon’s residents are choosing to spend more of their money in other places than do residents of other towns, and that Ripon city centre needs more shops to improve what’s called ‘comparison’ shopping. The way to capture lost spending in Ripon is to provide new premises suitable to those retailers that draw Ripon’s shoppers elsewhere. Anecdotal comments are that residents are travelling specifically to ‘M&S’ in other towns, especially the new food store in Harrogate. There’s a new ‘M&S’ store being built in Northallerton as well. Such is the strength of the brand.

But food stores are classified as ‘convenience’ shopping, and the 2014 report showed that Ripon is already well supplied with it. The out-of-centre Aldi store was permitted partly because of the contribution it could offer to residents seeking ‘value’ or discount shopping. Food shopping patterns are changing, with increasing numbers of households choosing to use both discount and regular traders. So, how would ‘M&S’ contribute to Ripon’s shopping needs, especially as it’s described as being a food store without fashion and other such ‘comparison’ merchandise?

It’s likely that existing food traders will object to a planning application because it will be diverting spending away from them and away from the city centre. It will be interesting to learn – if possible – how much of the spending that is currently escaping Ripon might be retrieved if ‘M&S’ and the other three shops proposed alongside it were given the go-ahead. Indeed, might it be that spending would come to Ripon from places elsewhere?

If the proposal is permitted, a couple of other points will need to have been considered. The planning application is likely to be for ‘A1 use’; that is, for shops – not for business units, food and drink outlets, finance or commercial offices. Over time this might change, of course.

And then there’s parking. The Civic Society is known for its preference for removing parking from the Market Place and local concern about the amount of parking in the city centre is very well known. This proposal would bring another 154 parking spaces to Ripon. They would be well located in relation to the by-pass and to the principal signed entrance for visitors to the city centre and its attractions. The proposal includes a new footpath, though its distance from the city centre makes it too far for comfortable walking, especially when carrying other shopping. It should also provide proper information to visitors, and signage to the city centre and its attractions. There is a bus lay-by proposed in the site. Whether or not the 36 bus can be redirected to serve this site, as the proposers suggest, is there an opportunity to route the local bus service to the site to provide an informal ‘park and ride’ service? Certainly, we should be encouraging alternatives to car journeys as much as possible.

Finally, let’s take a look at the Rotary Way site itself. Currently, Harrogate’s Local Plan from 2001 puts it outside the city’s ‘development limit’. When the first draft of the City Plan was exhibited it proposed that the limit could be extended to include this site, although no proposals for its use were then made. Ground condition records appear to show that the site can be built on. So, is this proposal preferable to other possibilities? Obviously land value plays an important part in what development alternatives might be viable but might this site be suitable for small business units, a hotel or extra care housing?

The proposers have come up with an option and this deserves a considered decision; but let’s not be swayed by the allure of the brand; there’s much more to it than that.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.