SETTING OUT THE CHURCH – PART 3: THE CHURCH ASLEEP – AND RE-AWOKEN

In the Guildhall in London there is a pair of pictures, by John Millias, of a small girl sitting in a Georgian box pew. The first, titled ‘My First Sermon’, shows her alert and upright, listening with great attention and interest. When this picture appeared, the Archbishop of Canterbury lauded the girl as an example to everyone who went to church, to pay strict attention to what was said.

Its companion picture appeared a little later; now the girl is slumped in the pew, her hat by her side, fast asleep. Its title is ‘My Second Sermon’. The Archbishop again had a moral to draw – it was a dreadful warning to the clergy that they needed to engage the attention of the congregation.

These pictures were painted in 1863 and 1864, but the pew in which the girl sits could be from any time in the previous 150 years. It is high-backed, lined with green baize and a private space. Such box pews, which came into the church in the early 18th century, were the equivalent for the middle and upper classes of their drawing room, where the family gathered together away from the eyes of others. Some were luxuriously appointed – even with their own fireplaces.

In the middle of this compartmented church stood the pulpit – probably a three-decker, with, at the lowest level, a desk for the Clerk who led the congregation in the responses to the vicar, a desk for the vicar in the middle, and a pulpit at the top from which he would preach. He alone was sufficiently elevated to see into the box pews. The pulpit was the focus of the church; Holy Communion was rarely celebrated. When it was, those who wanted to receive it went from their pews into the east end; in an old church this was beyond the screen, which separated them from the rest of the church – though in some churches, like the extraordinary St Mary’s in Whitby, an elevated family pew across the archway effectively did the same job of separation.

The Georgian church in England was respectable but dull. The church interiors were whitewashed, the boards with the Ten Commandments and the Lord’s Prayer were the only decoration at the east end, while at the west end there might be other boards listing generous benefactors to the parish. The vicars – the parsons of Jane Austen’s time – lived, usually, a comfortable life, often in parsonages that were larger than the churches they served.

It was against this background that the ‘Nonconformists’ had their rise. Their chapels were at first humble buildings on a domestic scale, but as the 18th century wore on they developed a style of their own, usually adapting classical styles of architecture to make themselves distinctive from the usually-Gothic Church of England – Coltsgate Hill Chapel in Ripon and York’s impressive Centenary Methodist Chapel are typical 19th-century examples. It was really only in the later 19th century that Nonconformists began to use Gothic, too.

By the early 19th century there were rumbles of disquiet in the Church of England, too, about both its doctrine and its liturgy and its buildings. The Oxford Movement, led by, among others, John Keble and John Henry Newman, argued that the doctrine and liturgical practices of the Church of England were compatible with those of the Roman Catholic Church. They promulgated these ideas in a series of writings called ‘Tracts for the times’ – hence they were also known as ‘Tractarians’. This was revolutionary stuff, and shook the Anglican Church.

And in parallel with the Oxford Movement, a Cambridge Group – the Camden Society – set out to revolutionise the architecture of the church to accommodate what they regarded as the ‘proper’ liturgy. Its members railed against the state of many churches: ‘the floor is of course strewed with filth, rubbish, deal forms, and unsightly and indescribable piles of deal woodwork . . .’ A Tudor tomb of ‘the broken and whitewashed effigies of a knight and his two wives, displayed, when we visited it, two old brooms, a thick ash stick, a rusty tin pot, a blue rag, a brick, a spade without a handle, a boy’s slate and some bits of old iron, on the top.’

The combined efforts of the Oxford Movement and the Cambridge Camden Society brought about a new way of looking at church buildings. It led to an appreciation that properly-conducted worship and decent churches went together, and gradually, through the 19th century, churches were restored to a state we could recognise today – decent, orderly and, often, colourful. New churches were built to accommodate the newly-discovered ritual – though ritualists were often condemned by their lower-church contemporaries, with law-suits taken (sometimes successfully) against them.

Even into the 20th century there were many who objected to candles on altars, the wearing of vestments and other ‘Popish’ things in churches. But gradually much of the Church of England has accepted many of what were once seen as ‘extreme’ practices – even robed choirs were once seen as evidence that a parish was on its way either to Rome or to hell.

And church architecture has not stood still, either. Although traditionally-organised churches – nave, chancel, sometimes a tower or transepts – continued to be built, there were moves to be more inclusive by having churches as single spaces, where everyone could both see and hear. After World War II it was felt that new churches should be useful for community activities, too, so they were designed with various ingenious ways for using them also as church halls.

In the latter half of the 20th century, many churches ceased to be mostly rectangular boxes and developed central altars – not always with success. And though few new churches are being built today, they are looking both back to the long history of church design and to a future in which they will, perhaps, have to exist much more on their own resources if they are to survive – often used by several denominations. It will be interesting to see how they develop.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.