In 1546 the religious reformer John Calvin persuaded the city council in Geneva to abolish taverns and to open cafés instead. Not content with that, he also attempted to regulate what went on inside those newly-established cafés. Conversation had to be decorous and without vulgarity, and bawdy songs were completely banished (that perhaps throws an interesting light on 16th century Geneva – or perhaps just on human nature); food could not be served unless Grace was said both before and after the meal; every establishment had to provide a Bible, in French, so that it could be referred to in the course of those decorous conversations. Calvin’s reform of people’s pleasure didn’t last long. Few went to the cafés, and very soon the taverns reopened.
Calvin might have had more luck in modern Britain. Now, coffee shops proliferate, in Ripon as elsewhere. They have obviously tapped into a need for such things – or, more probably, they have used clever marketing to persuade us that our life is not complete without a skinny latte or a frothy cappuccino.
In the meantime, pubs decline. The number of pubs in England is estimated at 48,000; but that number reduces by four each day – getting on for 1,500 each year. Perhaps the rise of the coffee shop and the decline of the pub are two ends of a see-saw; one goes down when the other rises. That might suggest that the see-saw will at some point be tipped the other way – can we expect the number of pubs to rise again, the coffee shops to decline? Or is the change permanent; has the age of the pub passed for good?
Some pubs are converted into houses; others to other uses: in 2010 the Campaign for Real Ale (CAMRA) reported that between January and November that year more than 200 former pubs had become convenience stores. The rate of attrition has, if anything, increased since then.
The website ‘The Lost Pubs Project’ (www.closedpubs.co.uk) lists the losses that the compilers know about by county (the Yorkshire list has 2665 entries) and then by city or town. And at www.ripon.org there is a list of Ripon’s pubs: there are around a dozen still serving customers, but 41 that have been lost over the years. They include five in the Market Square, and two each on High, Low and Water Skellgate. Recent losses include The Fleece at the foot of Allhallowgate, now housing, and The Wheatsheaf, now replaced by the architecturally nugatory care home where Harrogate Road meets the bypass.
One of the latest to close has been The Station on North Road. A recent application to demolish the building to make way for apartments has received objections, not least from the Civic Society. It is a prominent building within the Ripon Conservation Area, and has some historic and architectural interest; it apparently dates from the mid-19th century and is a clear reminder of the development of north Ripon with the coming of the railway in the 1840s. What appears to be an early-20th-century extension to the frontage adds to its charm as a simple roadside inn. Its demolition would be detrimental to the look of this approach from the north into the city.
The Society believes that it is fully capable of being refurbished to again act as a focal point for the community – especially if a comprehensive solution to the future use of the adjacent Auction Market site is found. The building is not listed, and is therefore more vulnerable – there have been many reports of unauthorised demolition of pubs around the country, including some that were listed and others that were under consideration for listing. Of course, there is no suggestion that such a move is contemplated for The Station – but what we need for it, and for all such buildings, is stronger protection.
The outlook is mixed. Until very recently a pub that wasn’t listed or in a Conservation Area could be demolished, or have its interior or its exterior changed, without planning consent. From 2005 the law changed to allow change of use from a ‘drinking establishment’ to a restaurant, an office or a shop as ‘permitted development’ – so, again, without having to seek consent.
A couple of very recent changes have made the situation slightly more hopeful. Local groups now have the right to nominate pubs (as well as other buildings) as ‘Assets of Community Value’ (ACV); there are criteria that must be met, but if the building meets them, the buildings must be registered by the local authority as ACVs. Once registered, an ACV is protected in three ways – if the owner decides to sell, or to grant a lease of at least 25 years, community interest groups can ask to be treated as potential bidders, and they then have six months to put together a bid; the owner cannot sell to anyone else during that time.
Once it’s an ACV, a building loses the change-of-use permitted development rights. Even more importantly, a pub with an ACV listing would need planning permission for demolition, even if not listed or in a Conservation Area. Another possibility is that the local authority can restrict permitted development rights with what’s known as an ‘Article 4 direction’ – these are usually used to cover a whole area, but could be used for individual buildings, like pubs.
This is largely terra incognita – ACVs have not been around for very long, though earlier this year Otley was the first place in the country to organise a mass ACV registration, with 19 of its pubs being added to the local authority’s list. Ripon Civic Society will consider the progress ACVs make, and how they are applied, with interest. In the meantime, if you’re in one of Ripon’s pubs over the Christmas season, consider just how much you’d miss it if it was no longer there for you to enjoy.
