Pretty. In many ways it’s an odd word to use when describing architecture – certainly one not normally used by serious architectural historians. So it is rather a shock to come across the country’s best-known architectural writer, Sir Nikolaus Pevsner, compiler of ‘The Buildings of England’ and editor of another multi-volume work, the Pelican History of Art, using it as a term of approval.
In the list he compiled, in 1974 for the Daily Telegraph, of his ‘favourite buildings’ he included not only ‘the façade of Ripon Cathedral’, but also King’s College Chapel, Cambridge, which he described as ‘Perpendicular – nothing prettier in the whole of England.’
What are we to make of that? What, indeed, do we think ‘pretty’ means? The Oxford English Dictionary notes that when the word is used of a person it means ‘attractive in a delicate way without being truly beautiful’; of an object it means ‘pleasing to the eye or the ear.’ But it can also have negative connotations: ‘We’re in a pretty pickle’ is certainly not a term of approbation.
The word derives from an Old English word prættig, which is related to a Middle Dutch term meaning ‘brisk, clever’, which in its turn came from a West Germanic term meaning ‘trick’. So ‘pretty’ has a range of meanings, from admirable, pleasing and ‘nice’, through skilful and clever, to cunning and deceitful. It can often be used to ‘damn with faint praise’.
So what did Pevsner mean about King’s College? Nowhere in his description of the chapel in his Cambridgeshire volume of ‘The Buildings of England’ does he describe it as ‘pretty’; it’s ‘original’, ‘ingenious’, ‘superb’, ‘clear and crisp’, ‘rich’, ‘magnificent’ and ‘handsome’, but not ‘pretty’.
Perhaps we must assume that he was referring to the chapel’s interior, with its spreading fan vault – though he may equally have meant its wonderful position beside the lawns that overlook the Backs. We know that he had a fondness for its style, Perpendicular, that peculiarly English version of Gothic. And perhaps some of that prettiness came, too, from the stone with which it was built.
The wide variety of building stones in Britain means we can find the look of local buildings changing quickly as we move around the country. And some building stones have always been thought ‘prettier’ than others. Watchers of television property programmes will know that ‘character’ is usually one of the most desirable of attributes that house-seekers want; ‘character’ often means the honey-coloured stones of Cotswold cottages or Ham stone houses in Somerset. Sometimes flint is acceptable as ‘pretty’, and old, mellow brick (rarely modern, machine-made brick) will do, too. Oh, and can it be thatched, please? Thatch is one of the ultimate attributes of ‘prettiness’.
Often, it’s when a group of such houses is found together, in a village or in a market town, that ‘prettiness’ is most appreciated – think of Cotswold villages like Broadway or Burford, or a town like Stamford in Lincolnshire.
How do other stones measure against these (to which we might perhaps add Bath stone and Portland stone)? Houses built of millstone grit are rarely described as being pretty, though they have their admirers. Buildings of chalk block (clunch) and of mud (cob) can look attractive, as can granite, but what about other materials? Timber-framed buildings are highly desirable, of course (though usually made less authentic than they originally were by exposing the frame), but there is often less enthusiasm about buildings constructed entirely of wood.
Given Pevsner’s liking for Modern Movement buildings, it would be good to report prettiness in a metal and glass building, but that’s not really how they are seen – respect and admiration, perhaps, but that warmth of feeling that describing something as ‘pretty’ usually implies, is absent. It’s absent, too, when we look at buildings of concrete.
To some architects, calling their work ‘pretty’ would be a term of abuse. They aimed at something powerful, perhaps masculine, and would have thought that ‘pretty’ buildings are feminine. It’s the same contrast we find between the ‘Last Judgement’ painted by John Martin and a flowering bower painted by Fragonard. Among the ‘masculine’ architects we can count, perhaps, are William Butterfield (his Baldersby St James church is a good example of his style), William Burges at Studley Royal and Skelton-on-Ure churches and, more recently, David Chipperfield at the Hepworth Gallery in Wakefield.
We can find the same sort of divide in interior decoration. Pevsner may have found the King’s College Chapel fan vault pretty, but the vault would also appeal to his love of logical structure. When it comes to decoration that is applied to walls and ceilings rather than being part of the structure, we find definite moves toward prettiness – think of the pastel-coloured ceilings of Robert Adam, or the fashion for delicate Etruscan-inspired patterns applied to walls. And even William Morris’s wallpapers were, sometimes to his disgust, called ‘pretty’.
Even something as tough as ironwork can be pretty – 18th-century gates with playful decoration of garden implements or flowers were intended to impress visitors with their beauty. On the other hand, 19th-century ironwork was often heavy and ponderous.
Should ‘pretty’ be part of the architecture-appreciator’s vocabulary? It’s harmless word, and a useful one, too, when used to sum up an overall impression of a place; we all know (perhaps a little vaguely) what it means, even if our personal definition of prettiness might not coincide with that of other people. Yet perhaps it’s another example of words we reach for when we want an easy response; one that might, with a little more thought, have been replaced with a more accurate description.
So, please carry on using ‘pretty’ if you wish – after all, it’s use is sanctioned by Pevsner – but bear in mind that it perhaps shows less than wholehearted enthusiasm than you intended. Pevsner’s ‘rich’, ‘magnificent’ and ‘handsome’ carry much more meaning.
