HIGH PRAISE AT ST MICHAEL’S TOWERS

The recent recognition of the importance of the tower on How Hill, south of Fountains Abbey, as part of the planned landscape laid out by John Aislabie and his successors at Studley Royal has brought back into focus one of the many ancient hilltops formerly dedicated to the archangel St Michael.

The tower that now stands on the isolated hilltop is well documented in Mark Newman’s book ‘The Wonder of the North’, which was discussed in this column in February this year. The book tells us that the tower was built as the termination of one of the main vistas across the estate from Studley Royal House. Its form, Mr Newman suggests, especially the pyramid-pointed roof, was influenced by the Pyramid Gate at Castle Howard, designed by Vanbrugh and built in 1719.

The chapel as it appears today is the result of several periods of construction and alteration, and a variety of uses – not just as an eyecatcher and a viewpoint for the estate, but possibly also as a gambling den and certainly as a cottage; it was also used as a Home Guard lookout in World War II. But the current building was not the first on the site.

The hill had already been used by the Fountains Abbey monks as the site of a chapel. Possibly built about 1200, it was certainly there in 1346 when the monks disputed with the canons of Ripon Minster about its ownership. One of its purposes was to hold a light to guide pilgrims through the dense forest which stretched for miles around the hill. The chapel was dedicated to St Michael.

Hill-top shrines have been dedicated to the Archangel since at least 490 AD; in that year, tradition says, the Michael appeared several times to the local bishop on Mount Gorgano in southern Italy, promising protection from pagan enemies. No doubt the mountain top reminded the faithful of the celestial war Michael fights with the dragon in the Book of the Revelation.

In the same year, it is said, same Cornish fishermen saw the Archangel standing on a rocky ledge on the western side of what we now know as St Michael’s Mount in Cornwall – like How Hill, now owned by the National Trust. The Priory on the summit of St Michael’s Mount was founded in 1135 by the Abbot of its cross-channel companion, Mont St Michel. St Aubert, who first built the French version, was commanded to do so in another vision – but this was as late as 708 AD. Perhaps because St Michael’s Mount had the prior claim to saintly visitation, the monks of Mont St Michel never allowed it to become as rich – or as architecturally interesting – as their abbey.

As at How Hill, the monks who subsequently occupied St Michael’s Mount set up a lantern the top of the island; in the Middle Ages pilgrims had to prove their faith by climbing to one of the highest pinnacles and sit in the remains of the lantern there, which formed a seat overhanging a fearsome precipice.

The urge to dedicate heights to St Michael lasted well into the Middle Ages, and in England many hilltop churches recognise him as their patron. In Wales, too, he was popular, and the remains of a chapel visited well into the seventeenth century still stand on the summit of Skirrid Fawr in the Black Mountains near Abergavenny, close to the rift attributed to an earthquake at the time of the Crucifixion.

In Devon one of the country’s smallest churches, St Michael de Rupe, sits on top of an eroded volcanic cone, 1,100 feet up on Brent Tor in Dartmoor. The 12th century church’s west wall is only three feet from the edge of a sheer drop, and the whole building is only 14 feet wide. It was built by the monks of Tavistock Abbey, and in 1232 they began an annual fair in what today is a very isolated spot.

Further west, on the edge of Bodmin Moor, is St Michael’s Chapel at Roche. A tall outcrop of granite suddenly rises up amidst the lunar landscape of the china clay pits north of St Austell, looking, as Pevsner wrote, ‘as improbable as if it were some nineteenth-century Victorian play of fantasy in a public park’. But this is the real thing, with the chapel, built in the early part of the fifteenth century, set high up on the rock, and reached today by iron ladders.

Burrow Mump, at Athelney on the Somerset Levels, is another of the National Trust’s St Michaels. A mile from King Alfred’s stronghold (and where he supposedly e burned the cakes), it may have provided a lookout point for his campaigns. There are indications that its height was raised artificially at some point in the past. On the top of the Mump is the tower of a medieval church dedicated to St Michael. It is joined to an unfinished and ruinous eighteenth-century gothic church, begun in 1724.

The National Trust’s Glastonbury Tor, which dominates the Somerset landscape for miles around is also crowned a tower, the only remaining part of 14th-century St Michael’s church. Beside the tower, where everyone could see the king’s displeasure, the last Abbot of Glastonbury was hanged after the Dissolution of the Monasteries in 1539.

Ridges around the hill are probably the remains of a prehistoric field system, established when the slopes were one of the few places in the Levels dry enough to cultivate, but they are said to be the remains of a Celtic spiral labyrinth, leading to the top of the Tor. Here, it is said, was one of the entrances to the Land of the Dead.

Recent research has identified a similar spiral up How Hill – this one interpreted as a pilgrim route representing the ‘rocky way’ of the Christian life. Or it may, again, be prehistoric earthworks. Whatever the truth, there is no doubt that the hilltops dedicated to the Archangel Michael have played a significant part in the history both of faith and of the nation.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.