In 1934 William Inge, Dean of St Paul’s Cathedral, retired from that post, which he’d held since 1911; he then became a columnist on a London newspaper. On a visit to the United States he was asked to describe himself, to which he replied ‘I was once a pillar of the church, but now I’m a column in the Evening Standard.’ Taking Inge’s play on words as its cue, this week we have a column about columns.
In its most basic form, a column, in architectural terms, is ‘a structural element that transmits, through compression, the weight of the structure above to other structural elements below.’ That probably sounds very dull and utilitarian, and no doubt the first columns were just the result of retaining pillars of stone to support the roof of a specially-hollowed-out cave. There must have been moments, even for primitive man, when the roof of the cave showed signs of collapse; it was probably at such a time that the first column as we would recognise it, specially constructed to bear the weight above it, was invented.
From such realms of speculation, we can turn to definite matters. As early as 2600 BC we know that the Egyptian architect Imhotep was building columns in his great buildings – and his columns were not just plain cylinders but were elaborately carved to resemble bundles of reeds and decorated on the capitals with lotus flowers. They were also painted in strong colours – red, yellow, green and blue. A thousand years later the Egyptians had become so adept at the use of columns that they could happily construct huge ones; at Karnak some are 24 metres – nearly 79 feet – tall. At the Persian capital of Persepolis the builders did even better, with columns of 30 metres. On Crete, the Minoans more modestly used inverted tree trunks as columns, only later building in stone.
In all these civilisations columns were very largely restricted to indoor use, but when the Greeks took up the challenge of columnar architecture and made it their own, they liked to show off with rows of perfect columns on the outsides of their temples – think of the Parthenon, with its sturdy columns with square tops of the style we know as ‘Greek Doric’ and with regular fluting from top to bottom – carved once the columns were in place, and perhaps harking back to the reed-bundles of Egyptian columns.
The Greeks developed several variations on the column – the Ionic, with its spiralling capitals like rams’ horns (the sort of columns that we find on the front of Ripon Town Hall) and the Corinthian, which is characterised by carvings of acanthus leaves on the capitals. These variations – known as the Orders, were taken over by the Romans, who added some of their own variations – the plain Tuscan, the type reproduced in large numbers in the Pillared Hall of Wentworth Woodhouse in South Yorkshire, the Roman Doric, slimmer and more elegant that its Greek counterpart, and, by combining Ionic and Corinthian, the elaborate Composite, often reserved for the most elaborate and prestigious buildings.
With the collapse of the Roman Empire we might have expected that the Orders would be forgotten – but in fact they went on being used, albeit often in more rudimentary forms. ‘Dark Ages’ churches, especially in the south of Europe, continued to use columns with capitals in a recognisably Ionic or Corinthian style. Even in the Middle Ages, when we might expect to find Gothic architecture in the vanguard, we can still trace the Roman Orders in capitals – for example, in the eastern part of Canterbury Cathedral. And even in humble places, like the undercroft of the Norman manor house at Burton Agnes in East Yorkshire, the so-called ‘waterleaf’ capitals are distant memory of Ionic, perhaps.
Norman columns are massive, as they had to support great weight, and architectural technique wasn’t developed sufficiently to take heavy loads on thinner columns. But to lessen the apparent mass, the Normans often decorated their columns with patterns – diamonds, chevrons and spirals; the best known examples are in Durham Cathedral. But from the early 12th century it was realised that columns could be made thinner, especially if they supported pointed, Gothic, arches which better distributed the weight above them.
And with the birth of Gothic architecture we find a wide variety of columns – plain cylinders, octagonal and multi-shafted columns, columns with attached thinner columns, sometimes in the contrasting black polished limestone usually known as ‘Purbeck Marble’ but in the north more likely to come from Nidderdale (as it did at Fountains Abbey) or from Wolsingham (as at Durham).
Architectural historians can provide accurate dates for Gothic buildings by looking at the shape of the columns; but in the rational age of the 18th century an (unsuccessful) attempt was made by writer and architect Batty Langley to produce ‘Orders’ of Gothic – which were really the classical Orders in Gothic dress. Langley’s Gothic Orders didn’t catch on, though we can sometime spot them in garden buildings where they are used for decorative rather than structural purposes.
Until the 19th century columns were essential weapons in an architect’s armoury, as structural components needed to carry walls and other loads. But in the latter part of Victoria’s reign iron framing came in, and columns began to be used less for structure than for embellishment (though we have to acknowledge that even in the 18th century columns weren’t always load-bearing, as the half columns on Ripon Town Hall will testify).
By the late 20th century we had, for most practical purposes, abandoned the column – except in its plainest form of a steel girder, perhaps. Anyone building a classical or Gothic (or even Egyptian) column today does it in an allusive way, not practically. Perhaps the most egregious example of this is not too far away – the Greek Doric columns fronting the exhibition hall adjacent to Harrogate’s Royal Hall, from the tops of which protrude the steelwork. It’s all a far cry from the Parthenon.
