Ichabod. Not a word you meet every day, but one that has its uses.
Ichabod was the son of a priest at the shrine of Shiloh, noted in the 1st Book of Samuel. He was born prematurely after his mother went into shock on hearing that the Ark of the Covenant, the sacred chest that contained two stone tablets on which Moses had inscribed the Ten Commandments, had been captured by the Philistines.
She named the child Ichabod, which means something like ‘Where is the glory?’ or ‘The glory has departed’. And the name came to be used as a catchphrase when anyone wanted to suggest that some former glorious past has now faded from memory. Thus, Charlotte Brontë in her novel ‘Vilette’ has her heroine Lucy Snowe speak of a bundle of love letters from Dr Bretton as ‘most dear still, though Ichabod was written on their covers’ .
‘Ichabod’ would be a good motto for a book first published in 2015 with the title ‘Fallen Glory’. In more than 600 pages the author, James Crawford, catalogues some of the vanished – or almost vanished – architectural wonders through the ages. Some of them will be familiar – Crawford begins with the Tower of Babel, tracing its origins to 5,000 BC and bring its story up to date with the attempt by Saddam Hussein to rebuild it, starting in 1978; Saddam’s version ground to a halt on his defeat, and much was levelled or damaged by the actions of the invading forces.
Familiar, too, may be the Palace of King Minos at Knossos on the island of Crete – though as Crawford points out, much of what visitors see today are imaginative concrete reconstructions put up by the archaeologist Sir Arthur Evans. The citadel at Mycenae, with its iconic Lion Gate – possibly home to Agamemnon (if he existed) – is another of the Ichabod structures that are well known. Others include the Temple of Solomon in Jerusalem, the Library of Alexandria in Egypt, Rome’s Forum, Paris’s Bastille, and the former incarnation of St Paul’s Cathedral in London, destroyed in the Great Fire of London.
How much do you know, though, of Amarna, the sun-worshipping city of the apostate Pharaoh Akhenaten (father – or possibly half-brother – of Tutankhamun), that flourished for only 17 years from 1348 BC? Of the Hippodrome of Constantinople or of Madinat al-Zahra near Cordoba, which lasted a more respectable 70 years? Of Karakorum in Mongolia, of Golconda in India or Vilcabamba in Peru? To these ancient examples, Crawford adds more-modern examples, including the Berlin Wall and the Twin Towers of the World Trade Centre.
We may, perhaps, add to Crawford’s list some of the world’s other famous ruined landmarks – Libya’s Leptis Magna, perhaps, or Angkor Wat in Cambodia – but perhaps we ought also to seek Ichabod nearer home. Old St Paul’s may have been a spectacular loss, but Britain can point to many other important buildings that have suffered total, or at least partial, loss.
In Ripon, we no longer have the great church that St Wilfrid built, said to be one of the greatest structures north of the Alps in its day, but destroyed in later raids. We do, of course, still have the crypt of Wilfrid’s church, one of the oldest built places of Christian worship on the country.
Also in Ripon we have the remains of the Chapel of St Anne in High St Agnesgate, next door to Thorpe Prebend house, which once served as the chapel for the ‘Maison de Dieu’ – almshouses for the poor. We have only part of the eastern end of the chapel – the nave, which would have housed the poor people, has long gone.
But if we want spectacular ruins along the lines of Leptis Magna or Madinat al-Zahra we don’t have to travel far – only to Fountains Abbey, perhaps Britain’s supreme monastic ruin. Henry VIII’s plundering of the monasteries and their subsequent abandonment to opportunist builders (who must have been delighted by the sudden availability of a seemingly-endless supply of ready-dressed stone) was perhaps the most devastating of all of the nation’s architectural disasters, carried out under the direction of Thomas Cromwell.
Some churches survived, either because new bishoprics were established – for example at Gloucester, where the abbey church was taken over as the cathedral – or were taken over by the local community as their parish church, as at St Albans. Sometimes the churches were too large and parts were demolished; the choir at Bridlington Priory was lost, and the nave of Bolton Priory was unroofed.
Castles, too, have had their struggles. By their nature they can have expected assault, but many stayed intact until the time of the Civil Wars, when the Parliamentarian troops were frequently ordered by another Cromwell, Oliver, to ‘slight’ the building – in other words to demolish part of it (usually by gunpowder) to ensure it could no longer be used. Dorset’s Corfe Castle, Kenilworth Castle in Warwickshire and, nearer here, Helmsley and Spofforth Castles are among ‘the ruins that Cromwell knocked about a bit’.
Country houses, too, have been lost. The great house at Studley Royal, former seat of the Marquesses of Ripon, went in a fire in 1946. Other notable local losses have been Thirkleby Hall near Thirsk, designed by James Wyatt, was demolished in 1927 after the death of the heir to the owning family in the Great War, and Halnaby Hall near Darlington, where Lord Byron spent his ill-fated honeymoon; the house was demolished in 1952. Two parts of Halnaby remain; the decorative plasterwork from its dining room was transferred to the Bridge Inn at Walshford, and a chimneypiece is now in Kensington Palace.
We must regret the loss of all such buildings, though one could argue that we are reminded by their vanishing of what Dr Johnson called ‘The Vanity of Human Wishes’. Should we strive to save important buildings? Certainly we should, as they are a central part of our history and culture. And even if, reluctantly, we have to let them go, they will remain in memory, whether universally, like Babel or Knossos, or locally, like our lost houses and churches.
