A FUTURE FOR THE SPA BATHS?

Where has the debate on the Spa Baths got to? There have been various meetings on the subject – Ripon City Council has considered the matter, Cllrs Kenn Hart and David Parnaby have held a public meeting about the form that the replacement pool should take, and Ripon Civic Society held a meeting last week to debate possible futures for the existing building.

The outcome of these meetings as far as the existing Spa Baths building is concerned has been remarkably consistent – that the Baths building, especially the frontage facing Park Street and the important Pump Room interior, must be kept in public use. The motion passed by the City Council doesn’t quite manage the words ‘public use’, though it is implied: it says that the Council requires ‘detailed discussion with the Borough Council and other interested organisations to ensure that the future of the facade and pump room of the Spa Baths is secured, and that any redevelopment to the site is both sympathetic and in keeping with the architecture and general ambience of the immediate area, and that there is full consultation with this Council and the citizens of Ripon.’

There has also been a great deal of disquiet about the accelerated timetable that Harrogate Borough Council is attempting to impose, to get in its planning consent for housing before the Local Development Framework brings in changes next October. After that there will be a requirement for more ‘affordable homes’ on any development, so the Council calculates the site will be worth less. But this bean-counting argument is not one on which to base a decision about one of Ripon’s iconic buildings.

The developments allowed for listed buildings like the Spa Baths are overseen by the Local Authority – but authorities have to take account of the Government’s Planning Policy Guidance document, known as PPG 15. Certain phrases are particularly appropriate in the case of the Spa Baths:
• ‘Once lost, listed buildings cannot be replaced; and they can be robbed of their special interest as surely by unsuitable alteration as by outright demolition. They represent a finite resource and an irreplaceable asset.’
• Consideration should be given to ‘the extent to which the proposed works would bring substantial benefits for the community, in particular by contributing to the economic regeneration of the area or the enhancement of its environment.’
• ‘In principle the aim should be to identify the optimum viable use that is compatible with the fabric, interior, and setting of the historic building. This may not necessarily be the most profitable use.’
• ‘If a building is so sensitive that it cannot sustain any alterations to keep it in viable economic use, its future may nevertheless be secured by charitable or community ownership, preserved for its own sake for local people and for the visiting public.’

Because the Spa Baths building is listed and in the Ripon Conservation Area, Harrogate Borough Council cannot give itself approval for its own plans; they have to go to the Secretary of State for consideration. The officials who consider the application for the Secretary of State will take these and other statements in favour of the preservation and public use of threatened listed buildings into consideration when making a decision.

More than that – they will have to take into consideration the concerns and opinions of local people. And increasingly the people of Ripon are coming together in opposition to the plans to sell the site for housing. We urge Harrogate Council to abandon its straightjacket timetable to allow more time for sensible consideration of the possible alternatives for the Spa Baths – and to allow imagination and vision to triumph over stultifying economics.

As one of the Freemen of Ripon, HRH The Prince of Wales, has written, ‘ I am not prepared to sit back and see this great legacy of historic buildings needlessly squandered, especially as, with a little imagination, they can become real assets to their local communities, offering job opportunities and focus for local regeneration schemes.’

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.