As traffic problems again hit Ripon, David Winpenny, Co-Chairman of Ripon Civic Society, asks for the thinking about our city centre to be much more forward-looking.
In the late 19th century an official report predicted that if the amount of horse-drawn traffic increased at its current rate, the streets of London would soon be up to 12 feet deep in horse droppings.
This dire prediction comes to mind as Ripon once again attempts to struggle with the horse’s successors on our streets – the cars, vans, lorries and buses that are having to develop new patterns of travel in our difficult network of narrow streets. Even as the 19th-century official put steel-nibbed pen to foolscap paper, things were changing; horse-drawn traffic had only a few years left before the internal combustion engine took over. And with the costs of driving petrol- and diesel-fuelled vehicles becoming ever steeper, perhaps we are on the verge of another such shift.
In the meantime, of course, we need to live with what we have. And in Ripon, what we have is a small city with, in the centre, a street plan that dates largely from medieval times. That gives us lots of problems. Such narrow streets were not constructed for the sort of traffic that we throw at them. And because Ripon is so small, it is difficult to divert the traffic around the historic core, as is done in, for example, York, Durham and Cambridge.
With Coltsgate Hill closed, we have extra problems. They will not be solved by motorists getting impatient in traffic queues, or by seeking devious alternatives through streets that were not made for such traffic flows. The problems will no doubt sort themselves out in a few weeks when people have become accustomed to using new routes. Perhaps more people will be encouraged to leave their car at home and walk to school with their children, or cycle to their place of work; after all, Ripon is really small enough for most parts to be easily accessible on foot or on a bike. We could then leave the roads for people who really need to use them – people who are disabled or old or parents with very young children, for example.
And once we are in a new stasis, perhaps we need to think much longer-term. Do we really want our streets always clogged with traffic? Or should we have a new vision that finds logical and practical ways of freeing Ripon’s historic centre? We all know the problems spots – Duck Hill, the dangerous corner from North Street into the Old Market Place and especially Low and High Skellgate. Low Skellgate, especially, has long been a horror – but with a little thought in the past it could have been solved easily with a link road from Water Skellgate across to Harrogate Road before the new houses were built.
If we do not take decisions about what we want to see in the future, we shall constantly be having the same debates for years to come. And what should our vision for the future encompass? Here are two suggestions. The Market Square should be made traffic-free and returned to the citizens and visitors as an open space, as it was originally planned. And the dangerous Minster Road should be closed to through traffic – it is a nonsense that our greatest building is degraded in this way.
How these wishes should be made into reality needs intense discussion – but unless that discussion happens, we shall find ourselves even deeper in the type of mire the late 19th-century report predicted for London.
