What can one of Ripon’s least-admired buildings teach us about architectural good manners? asks David Winpenny, Co-Chairman of Ripon Civic Society.
The centre of Ripon is distinctly fortunate in having largely escaped those architectural excrescences that often mar the centres of our towns and cities. Look round the Market Square, for example, and all appears, in general, harmonious.
This reflection comes about from the visit by the Chief Executive of English Heritage, Simon Thurley, last month. On a rapid tour though the city centre he stopped in the Square and looked around. And what did his eye light upon in particular? The obelisk, of course. The Town Hall. And then he pondered the Town Hall’s neighbour, the National Westminster Bank building.
It has long been fashionable in Ripon to decry the NatWest as an unworthy eyesore, letting down the architectural side in a brash and uncaring manner. How could the nineteen-sixties inflict this example of architectural bad manners on this historic city?
But is it so bad? Indeed, is it any worse that some of its neighbours? What about the Yorkshire Bank and its neighbour Drinks Well on the other side of the Town Hall? Are they better? Well, you may say, they fit in with the Wakeman’s House beside them. Certainly – but only because they ape the exposed beams of the old building. The Wakeman’s House beams were exposed in a rush of Romanticism in, probably, the 1930s – the same era that the black-painted laths were applied to the Yorkshire Bank. Is this good manners, or just dishonesty, making them seem more ancient than they warrant?
Burton’s store on the west side of the Square offers another angle to this question of architectural good manners. It is definitely of its period, and one might quibble that its extra height ignores the roofline of the buildings alongside it, but it pays handsome compliment to both the traditional brick of many of the surrounding buildings, and also, with its columns, to the Town Hall. Opposite is The Arcade, a schizophrenic affair. Its fake columns on the Square might be supposed to herald something worthwhile. Instead it is 90s ‘shopping-style’ with few redeeming (and some damning) features.
West of the Market Square the new Booths supermarket is gradually going up. It remains to be seen how its style and materials interact with the rest of the city, though as it goes up it looks like a large liner come to rest on a very small island. What it is unlikely to be, though, is a thoroughly contemporary-style building. That is probably not the architects’ or the developers’ fault; they have to work within very strict guidelines that seem to militate against good modern design.
Which brings us back to the NatWest. Simon Thurley commented that it was a decent design and very much of its time. It retains the verticality of many buildings in the Square and particularly of the Town Hall beside it. It has some interesting materials on the façade. It respects the roofline of the adjacent structures, and is largely self-effacing. You can quarrel with the detail – the slightly unsettling aspect of the way alternate windows are upside down, and the statue of St Wilfrid in his ‘bath’ might have been better handled. And by re-shaping the ground floor facade with a more ‘olde worlde’ shop front has actually worked against the ensemble of the building.
Yet what the NatWest does have, and which so many newer buildings lack, is a sense of its own worth and its date. We should take a fresh look at the NatWest, not just as a building but as a symbol of the need to be more daringly contemporary with our design. Architectural good manners are not a matter of trying to be as self-effacing as possible.
