ARE THINGS LOOKING UP FOR ROOFS?

Two Ripon roofs have been in the news in the last week. One, the subject of a letter in last week’s Ripon Gazette, was that of the new Booths supermarket building, now looming large in the development west of the marketplace. The other is the roof of the original Spa Baths building, now subject of a planning application from Harrogate Borough Council.

Fears were expressed that the supermarket building was getting a grey metallic cladding as its roof. This would have made it look like a pumped-up version of the ugly sheds that were put up alongside Boroughbridge Road, almost opposite the racecourse. It turns, out, though, that what was being applied was not the final surface but a sub-layer. The final stage of the roof is now underway, with slates are being laid over the metal sheeting.

Not far away, the discussion over the future of the Spa Baths has brought to light an interesting fact. The planning application design statement say that the 1904 building is roofed in Welsh slate. This is not accurate – the wings are in fact roofed in the more expensive Cumberland slate from the Lake District. This not just a superior material, but it is also more carefully laid, with the sizes of the slates graded from the largest at eaves level to the smaller ones at the roofline. Other roofs on the building are clay-tiled.

Does any of this matter very much? It does – because roofs give the city a great deal of its character. This is especially true in the city centre, where the older buildings display a wide variety of roof shapes, pitches and materials. As in its building materials, where stone and brick are used side by side, so Ripon is blessed with both pantiles and slate.

It is likely that before the 18th century many of the humbler cottages in the city had roofs of either thatch or heather – the shallow pitch of the roofs of some of the older houses is an indication of this. At times of greater prosperity – and when regulations about preventing fires started to come in – the thatch was replaced by pantiles, usually burned fairly locally. And in the 19th century, railways made it easier to transport materials from further away, and slates – Welsh and Lake District – became the fashionable roofing choice. New buildings used it, and some older structures were re-roofed. Sometimes, to save money, the side of the roof to the street was slate, the rear slope was pantiled.

There have been attempts to introduce new roof coverings – most objectionable are the concrete tiles of the sixties, which are not only thick, ugly and far too regular, but are also very heavy, causing ancient timbers to sag alarmingly. And we should count ourselves fortunate that ridged metal sheets have not invaded the city centre.

Perhaps now we could take a new step – not so much in the city centre, perhaps, but certainly with larger buildings on the periphery. Thin, for example, how much better the Boroughbridge Road sheds might have looked with roofs of grass or of sedum plants – and they would be more environmentally-friendly, too, absorbing rainfall and helping to stop the land drainage systems from overloading and causing floods.

And just think what an environmental halo Harrogate Borough Council could achieve by having such a roof for the new swimming pool – wherever it is built. Is this a prospect tempting enough for the idea to receive serious consideration?

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.