The story of the Spa Baths – and the fight to save the Park Street building as a public asset – has entered a new phase with Harrogate Borough Council’s (HBC) lodging of planning applications for the proposed new swimming pool adjacent to the Leisure Centre on Camp Close and for new houses and maisonettes on the Park Street site. The Council has also applied for Listed Building Consent to demolish the pool part of the Spa Baths building and convert the frontage.
Another significant move has also been the formation of The Ripon Spa Partnership, a grouping that includes Ripon Civic Society, Ripon Area Business Association and representatives of the pool’s user groups. Working to a blueprint suggested by the Prince of Wales’ Regeneration Trust, which helps to keep significant buildings in public use, the Partnership is aiming to find a sensible and viable solution for the Baths that does not require the emasculation that is offered by HBC.
Ripon Civic Society is very much in favour of Ripon having a new swimming pool, and recognises that the current Spa Baths are near the end of their useful life. The Society does, though, have particular concerns. Foremost, of course, is that there should continue to be public access to the important interiors of the 1904 buildings fronting Park Street. The current proposals are that the ornately-tiled foyer – the Pump Room – becomes the private entrance to the maisonettes and houses. There is also concern that there has not yet been a thorough investigation of the other interiors, where there are said to be tiles, similar to those in the foyer, hidden behind modern cladding. The architects of the new masionettes, which will occupy the structure if the plans are implemented, are not aware of them. Nor is English Heritage, which is relying on information supplied by HBC – and HBC (perhaps understandably) does not seem to want to investigate too closely.
The Civic Society is a statutory consultee on the planning applications, so, as well as commenting on the proposals for the Listed Buildings, it has also made its views known on both the plans for housing on the site and on the proposed new pool at Camp Close. The design of the houses is a very bland neo-Georgian, which neither matches the exuberance of the Edwardian frontage nor makes a modern statement. It is bland pastiche. This is not the architects’ fault; their initial proposals for a modern building were rejected by HBC’s officers. If there must be houses on the site – and the Civic Society does not believe there should – they should be statements of today, not an attempt at self-effacement.
The proposals at Camp Close, too, are worrying. Placing a new building alongside the existing Leisure Centre, rather than behind it, and constructing a large new car park, will interrupt views towards the Cathedral, and will also take open space dedicated to the young people of Ripon. The plans show large areas of blank, featureless walling, and the roof, sloping almost to the ground, is an open invitation to adventurous children or, worse, to vandals.
Ripon Civic Society is making its comments known on all these matters in its response to the planning applications. The Society urges everyone to look at the plans and to make their views known, too. The more response HBC receives, the more likely Ripon is to have a sensible outcome to this debate.
There is a public meeting, organised by the Save Our Spa Group and The Ripon Spa Partnership, for an open discussion of the Council plans, at Allhallowgate Methodist Church Hall at 7.30 pm on Monday 2 June.
