What’s in a name? asks David Winpenny, Co-Chairman of Ripon Civic Society.
‘Today we have naming of parts’. Henry Reed’s 1942 poem contrasting weapons training and nature came to mind this week when the names of two new parts of Ripon emerged – and the City Council rejected a request to take responsibility for future names.
Naming things may have been easy for Adam, who, according to the Book of Genesis, named all living creatures – but the process today is more complicated. More than a year ago the developers of the West of the Market Place development asked, as a matter of urgency, if the Civic Society had any ideas for the name of the scheme. The Society suggested Kendall Garth, based on the old name of the area, Treasurer’s Garth, and to commemorate Professor David Kendall, one of Ripon Grammar School’s most notable Old Boys, former professor of Mathematical Statistics at Cambridge and the father of modern probability theory. Professor Kendall’s daughter is the BBC’s Diplomatic Correspondent Bridget Kendall.
Nothing happened, and we were told that, instead, there was to be a competition in the Gazette for a name. That wasn’t forthcoming either, and now the development has a name of the developer’s marketing department’s choosing – the very pedestrian Market Gate. Will anyone call it that? Probably not, as it’s not distinctive. The area will no doubt come to be called Booth’s, after the supermarket.
The other name that’s come to public notice this week is that of the new link road from Coltsgate Hill to Blossomgate. It is to be called Marshall Way. The name comes from the former Marshall’s stonemasons yard that has been removed for the new road – the business is now in Whixley. This is perfectly acceptable; it refers to the history of the site and is distinctive. Perhaps ‘Way’ is a little pretentious, but roads these days seem never to be called ‘road’ or ‘street’. Another case is Caxton View, off Princess Road, presumably named because of the books from Caxton’s 15th-century press that used to be in Ripon Cathedral library – but in what way does this short street offer a ‘view’ of them?
It is Harrogate Borough Council (HBC) that is responsible for the naming of streets – but not for naming private developments like ‘Market Gate’. The criteria are straightforward; the Post Office and the Department for Transport require that there should not be more than one new street with the same name in any area, so that postmen and drivers (especially those with sat-nav) are not misled. This has sometimes led to differences of opinion when the City Council wanted something else. HBC offered the City Council the chance to take over the naming of the city’s new streets – a chance that was rejected at the Council meeting on Monday this week, mainly because of the costs involved.
It’s a shame that Ripon does not have the quirky street names of some places – think of Beverley’s ‘Toll Gavel’ and ‘Old Waste’ or York’s ‘Whip-ma-whop-ma-gate’. Only ‘Barefoot Street’ has any magic to it. We could hope that HBC will encourage developers to suggest more imaginative names in future.
One final thought. If names are important – and they are – perhaps HBC might like to consider its own name. With the hackles of some Riponians rising whenever Harrogate is mentioned, perhaps the Council should look to its neighbours like Ryedale and Craven, and change to something less territorial. Maybe we’d feel less dominated by, say, Claro District Council. As the examination papers used to say, discuss.
